← Back to Solutions Index

/createsolution v2.0

AI Board Review Workflow with Critique Loop

Executive Summary

The /createsolution command takes your program requirements (the "ask") and produces a comprehensive, multi-perspective solution design. It leverages three AI models (Claude, Gemini, and Codex) in two phases:

Phase 1 (Design): AI models analyze requirements and propose solutions.
Phase 2 (Critique): AI models challenge the solution for simplicity before finalization.

The result is a critique-refined solution that has been challenged for over-engineering, compared to industry best practices, and optimized for simplicity.

Use --skip-critique to bypass the critique loop for faster, simpler projects.

📝

Refines Requirements

Transforms your raw ideas into clear, professional specifications

🤖

Multi-AI Design

Gets design perspectives from Claude, Gemini, and Codex

🔍

Critique Loop

Challenges solution for simplicity and over-engineering

Refined Solution

Produces battle-tested, simplified design

The 11-Step Process (Default)

flowchart LR subgraph Input A[Program Ask] end subgraph "Steps 1-3" B[Name Approval] C[Refine Spec] D[Claude Analysis] end subgraph "Step 4: Review Board" E[Gemini] F[Codex] end subgraph "Steps 5-6" G[Synthesize v1] H[Optimize v1] end subgraph "Steps 7-10: Critique Review" direction TB I[Review Board] J[Refactor Plan] K[Re-Synth v2] L[Final Optimize] end subgraph Output M[Executive Site] end A --> B --> C --> D D --> E D --> F E --> G F --> G G --> H --> I I --> J --> K --> L L --> M style A fill:#ffd700,color:#1a1a2e style M fill:#4ade80,color:#1a1a2e style E fill:#4285f4,color:#fff style F fill:#10b981,color:#fff style D fill:#d97757,color:#fff style I fill:#a855f7,color:#fff style J fill:#a855f7,color:#fff style K fill:#a855f7,color:#fff style L fill:#a855f7,color:#fff
1
Name
Approve project
2
Refine
Format spec
3
Analyze
Claude proposal
4
Review Board
Gemini + Codex
5
Synthesize
Merge v1
6
Optimize
Review v1
REVIEW BOARD CRITIQUE (Steps 7-10)
7
Review Board
3 AI critics
8
Refactor
Plan changes
9
Re-Synth
Build v2
10
Final Opt
Polish v2
11
Present
Web deployment

The 7-Step Process (--skip-critique)

flowchart LR subgraph Input A[Program Ask] end subgraph "Steps 1-3" B[Name Approval] C[Refine Spec] D[Claude Analysis] end subgraph "Step 4: Review Board" E[Gemini] F[Codex] end subgraph "Steps 5-6" G[Synthesize] H[Optimize] end subgraph Output I[Executive Site] end A --> B --> C --> D D --> E D --> F E --> G F --> G G --> H --> I style A fill:#ffd700,color:#1a1a2e style I fill:#4ade80,color:#1a1a2e style E fill:#4285f4,color:#fff style F fill:#10b981,color:#fff style D fill:#d97757,color:#fff
1
Name
Approve project
2
Refine
Format spec
3
Analyze
Claude proposal
4
Review Board
Gemini + Codex
5
Synthesize
Merge ideas
6
Optimize
Critical review
7
Present
Web deployment

Review Board - Two Phases

Phase 1: Review Board Design (Step 4)

  • Focus on building solutions
  • High-level architecture
  • Technical implementation
  • Stack recommendations
  • Integration patterns

Phase 2: Review Board Critique (Step 7)

  • Focus on finding problems
  • Over-engineering detection
  • Industry comparison
  • Simplification opportunities
  • Red flags and risks

Three AI Perspectives

Claude
Orchestrator and Initial Analysis
Practical implementation focus
Infrastructure integration
+ Self-critique in Phase 2
Gemini
High-level reasoning
User flow and UX patterns
System integration
+ Industry comparison critique
Codex (ChatGPT)
Technical implementation
Code feasibility
Stack and tool choices
+ Technical debt analysis

Generated Artifacts (11 files)

{name}.md Refined requirements
{name}.claude.md Claude's analysis
{name}.gemini.md Gemini design review
{name}.codex.md Codex design review
{name}.final.v1.md First synthesis (archived)
{name}.critique.gemini.md Gemini critique
{name}.critique.codex.md Codex critique
{name}.critique.claude.md Claude self-critique
{name}.refactor.md Refactoring plan
{name}.final.md Final solution (v2)
index.html Executive presentation

Generated Artifacts (6 files)

{name}.md Refined requirements
{name}.claude.md Claude's analysis
{name}.gemini.md Gemini's review
{name}.codex.md Codex's review
{name}.final.md Synthesized solution
index.html Executive presentation

When to Use /createsolution

How to Invoke

Default (with critique loop - 11 steps)
/createsolution Build a stock portfolio tracker with alerts
Skip critique (faster - 7 steps)
/createsolution --skip-critique Add user authentication
View Full Design Document (Markdown)